If a home-service app asks to record work inside your house, the right response is not a quick yes. It is a short list of questions.
On 12 November 2026, MeitY Secretary S Krishnan chaired a meeting with Pronto, Urban Company, Snabbit and robotics companies about first-person video and sensor data collected in Indian homes and used to train physical AI models. The Economic Times reported the consultation first. Officials asked how the footage is collected, how long it is kept, how workers are told and paid, how family members' privacy is protected, and whether the data is sent to developers outside India.
This is not a verdict. MeitY is asking questions, not announcing that a company has broken the law. This article is also not legal advice. It explains what news reports and public statements say. For your own situation, please check with a lawyer who knows data protection law.
The story is not only about customer privacy. Housekeepers and cleaners on an opt-in service are wearing cameras in our homes. The same footage can be used to train robots that could eventually do that work. Before you consent, ask who is filmed, where the video goes, and what the worker is paid.
What MeitY asked
I could not read the full Economic Times exclusive, which is behind a paywall. The facts below come from the portions of that page that were visible, from ET's Morning Dispatch newsletter of 13 November, which I did read, and from MediaNama's 13 November report, which cites the ET exclusive.
According to the Morning Dispatch, three people in the know told ET that the ministry met representatives of Pronto, Urban Company, Snabbit and other technology and robotics companies on Thursday, 12 November. The meeting was triggered, one person briefed on the discussions said, by a home services platform equipping domestic workers with head-mounted cameras to record everyday household tasks, with the footage used to train physical AI models.
MeitY sought standard operating procedures for collecting, processing and storing such data, including safeguards for obtaining workers' consent and protecting the privacy of others captured in the recordings. ET reporter Pranav Mukul, one of the authors of the exclusive, also posted on X that the discussion covered worker consent, privacy and data sovereignty.
MediaNama, citing ET, reported further that officials asked whether platforms are selling or sending in-home footage to physical AI developers outside India, what data-sharing contracts they have, how long they keep the data, whether recordings are linked to workers' identities, what the footage is used for, and how much workers are paid for recording. A person aware of the meeting told ET, MediaNama reported, that "Pronto has been asked to submit a detailed representation on its SOPs and data collection practices."
After the meeting, Pronto said it "shared its current practices, which are designed to be compliant with applicable regulations." Some senior executives at the meeting criticised collecting data in India and selling it to overseas AI developers, saying it "did not put the country in a favourable light." Robotics startups, MediaNama reported, argued that India should build its own physical AI capabilities instead of only supplying data to foreign companies.
MeitY had already taken note of the issue in May 2026, BusinessLine reported at the time. The November meeting is a later, formal consultation, not the first time the ministry heard of the practice.
What the companies say
Among the three large instant home-service platforms, Pronto is the one that records inside homes. It does this through Verified, a paid, opt-in premium service it launched in July 2026. Housekeepers and cleaners wear head-mounted or body-mounted cameras during visits.
Pronto's public line has changed since May. That month, MediaNama reports, Pronto confirmed a pilot after an investor memo described it as developing a data business and piloting real-world training data with leading physical AI labs. Pronto said then that "all footage is deleted within 48 hours" and that it does not share data with third-party AI labs. MediaNama also reported that Pronto's privacy policy, last updated in November 2024, allowed it to use data "indefinitely" for research and did not mention video recording or AI training.
On 8 November 2026, Pronto told Inc42: "The raw footage is deleted immediately after the work is done, and no one ever accesses it. For 48 hours, an anonymised, end-to-end encrypted recording is available only to the customer, who can watch it in the app to check the work. After that, we use the anonymised footage for AI training, as our terms set out."
It also said customers are informed several times before recording begins, and that personally identifiable information is automatically blurred or removed on the device. It has not said who trains on the anonymised footage, or where that training happens.
In October, Pronto's founder and CEO, Anjali Sardana, set up Provision Labs, a San Francisco company that collects data to train and test physical AI systems. Inc42 asked how Pronto and Provision Labs work together, if at all. The company declined to comment. That unanswered question matters. It is not proof that footage from Indian homes is already going to the US firm. It is a reason to ask, clearly, where the video goes.
Urban Company and Snabbit have decided against recording inside homes, according to ET. In May, Urban Company founder Abhiraj Singh Bhal said: "We do not engage in any such activities, have never done so in the past, and have no plans to do so in the future." Snabbit said it ran a one-time assessment in a training centre and did not go ahead. It signed a mutual non-disclosure agreement with robotics data startup Human Archive, but said the agreement "did not create or imply any form of commercial or operational relationship."
Why the worker question matters as much as your privacy
It is easy to treat this as a story about your living room, your children, and whether a stranger can watch a video of your house. Those worries are real, and you should take them seriously. They are not the whole story.
The people wearing the cameras are domestic workers. Pronto told Inc42 that more than half of the professionals on Verified already earn over Rs 40,000 a month, and that workers feel safer knowing there is a record of their work. Inc42 noted that no independent study has confirmed that claim, and that Pronto did not separately spell out how much a worker is paid specifically for recording.
Much of the paid housework in Indian homes is done by women. The reports did not say who wears Pronto's cameras, but if it is mostly women, then women doing housework are being paid to train the robots that could one day replace them. That deserves more than a consent checkbox.
Inc42 put the labour point bluntly: Indian workers are training the robots that could eventually replace them. I agree that this is the question households should not skip. If you pay a little extra for a "verified" visit, you may also be helping to build the system that is meant, over time, to do the same job with fewer people. Consent that covers only "we will record the work" is not the same as consent that covers "this video may be used to train a robot."
In May, Apar Gupta of the Internet Freedom Foundation told MediaNama: "A monitoring service in the home and the onward sale of footage to third-party AI labs are two distinct purposes." Each purpose, he said, needs its own consent. Once footage leaves the company, or leaves India, it becomes harder to tell who is responsible for it and who still holds that consent.
What the law does, and does not, do yet
MediaNama's reading of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act is that companies may send personal data abroad unless the government restricts a country, and it has not restricted any so far. The DPDP Rules allow the government to set further conditions on such transfers, but those obligations take effect only in May 2027. Until then, MediaNama writes, no Indian law specifically stops companies from sending footage of Indian homes, workers and children to AI developers abroad.
Truly anonymised data falls outside the Act. MediaNama is careful on this point: blurring faces does not necessarily make footage of a person's home anonymous. A kitchen, a street view from a window, or a child's room can still identify a household even if faces are hidden.
None of this is a finding that Pronto, or anyone else at the meeting, has broken the law. It is a reminder that "we are compliant" and "the footage is anonymised" are claims you should test, not a reason to skip the questions below. This is not legal advice.
Five questions to ask before you consent
I have made the same argument about other tools that sit close to daily life, from consent when a watch is listening to a privacy checklist for new AI products in India and how to keep your ChatGPT, Claude and Gemini data more private. The habit is the same. Read what you are agreeing to, and keep the decision with you.
- Can I say no and still get the service I booked? If recording is bundled into the only slot on offer, or priced so that refusing it is impractical, that is not a meaningful choice. Ask whether a visit without a camera is available on the same terms.
- Who else may appear in the video, and how is their consent obtained? A household is not only the person who tapped yes in the app. Children, elders, visitors, neighbours and the worker herself may be in the frame. Ask how the company handles people who did not open the app.
- How long is the footage kept, and what does anonymised mean? Ask what is deleted, what is kept, whether "anonymised" means more than blurred faces, and whether you can watch, download or require deletion of the recording.
- Will this be used to train AI, and will it leave the company or India? Ask who the customer for the data is, whether any partner or overseas lab receives the video or data derived from it, and whether that is a separate permission from "record the work."
- How is the worker informed and paid for the recording? Ask what the person in your home was told, whether they can refuse the camera without losing work, and how they are paid for being recorded. The worker's dignity is part of the consent, not an afterthought. The wider jobs question is one I have already asked in what AI means for work in India.
Keep the yes or no with you
I am not saying you should never use a home-service app, or that recording can never be useful. A customer who wants to check that a job was done, and a worker who wants a record in case of a dispute, may both have reasons to want a video.
I am saying a confident "opt-in" button is not the end of the decision. Ask where the footage goes, who else is in it, how long it is kept, and what the person wearing the camera was told and paid. Then decide, on a visit you have actually understood, whether you still want the recording on.
At The Arthi AI Collective, I help students and working professionals use AI as a thinking partner, while keeping the judgement, and the consent, their own. If you want to learn to use these tools usefully and carefully, explore the programs.
Sources
- Pranav Mukul and Disha Acharya, "MeitY examines data collection by home services platforms for physical AI training", The Economic Times, 12 November 2026, 7:06 PM IST, updated 11:40 PM IST. The full exclusive was paywalled. I used only the visible headline, byline, date, synopsis and opening paragraphs from that page.
- "MeitY flags physical AI data; US data centre woes may help India", ET Morning Dispatch, updated 13 November 2026, 8:03 AM IST, which recaps the exclusive and was read in full
- Pranav Mukul, post on X, 12 November 2026, 8:56 PM IST
- Aakriti Bansal, "Is footage from Indian homes going abroad to train robots? MeitY questions Pronto and other platforms", MediaNama, 13 November 2026. Used for additional details MediaNama attributes to ET, for Pronto's May and November statements, for Urban Company and Snabbit's May remarks, for Apar Gupta's May comment, and for MediaNama's reading of DPDP and the May 2027 Rules date
- Shraddha Goled, "Pronto's Second Shift", Inc42, 8 November 2026
- Jyoti Banthia, "AI home-service startup Pronto sparks privacy concerns over wearable cameras", BusinessLine, 25 May 2026, 3:11 PM. This is the May controversy piece at the URL we were given, not a report of the 12 November meeting. Used only for the fact that MeitY had already taken note in May
Arthi Rajendran, The Arthi AI Collective